Skip to content
AlternativeMed

Compare Side by Side

Pick two or three supplements, herbs, teas or oils. You get an overview table, a goal-by-goal evidence chart, and the full details, all next to each other.

Comparing

Fish oil vs Algal (algae) oil

Overview

Fish oilAlgal (algae) oil
TypeSupplement
Omega-3 oil
Supplement
Omega-3 oil
What it isFish oil is a supplement that supplies the omega-3 fats EPA and DHA, which also come from oily fish. It reliably lowers blood triglycerides, but large…Algal oil is an oil from algae that supplies DHA, and in some products EPA, without using fish. In small trials it raised blood DHA about as well as s…
Best evidence Strong evidence
for: A source of EPA and DHA
Strong evidence
for: A fish-free source of DHA (and sometimes EPA)
Uses studied11 listed
3 good · 4 limited · 4 very limited
10 listed
3 good · 4 limited · 3 very limited
Side effects listed44
Who should be careful5 groups6 groups
Medicine interactions5 listed4 listed
PregnancyCaution or gap listedCaution or gap listed

Green outline = the better value in that row (stronger evidence, more well-supported uses, fewer side effects or interactions listed). A good score in one row does not make something the right choice for you.

Goal by goal

How strong the research is for each everyday goal. Empty means we have no study of it for that goal.

GoalFish oilAlgal (algae) oil
Heart & Blood Pressure Strong evidence
Lowering blood triglycerides
Good evidence
Raising DHA in the blood
Women's Wellness & Menopause Good evidence
Pregnancy: early birth and baby development
Limited evidence
Pregnancy and breastfeeding
Healthy Aging Mixed results
Dry eye
Limited evidence
Memory and thinking in older adults with mild memory de…
Focus & Memory – Limited evidence
Memory and thinking in older adults with mild memory de…
Joints & Mobility Limited evidence
Joint pain in rheumatoid arthritis
–
Mood Balance Very limited
Depression
–

Full details

Omega-3 oil

Fish oil

Fish oil is a supplement that supplies the omega-3 fats EPA and DHA, which also come from oily fish. It reliably lowers blood triglycerides, but large reviews found little or no effect on deaths or overall heart events, and the ev…

What it is studied for

  • A source of EPA and DHAhigh
  • Lowering blood triglycerideshigh
  • Heart attacks, strokes and other heart eventsmixed
  • Depressionvery-low
  • ADHD in children and teenagersagainst
  • Pregnancy: early birth and baby developmentmoderate
  • Joint pain in rheumatoid arthritislow

In short

The best evidence is that fish oil lowers triglycerides. For heart attacks, results are mixed: ordinary fish oil shows little or no effect, while a prescription EPA drug helped in one funded trial. Evidence is against a benefit for ADHD and macular degeneration. Atrial fibrillation and bleeding are the main cautions.

Main safety points

  • Fish oil can raise the chance of an irregular heartbeat (atrial fibrillation)
  • Fish oil may prolong bleeding time; tell your doctor if you take blood thinners
  • Fish or shellfish allergy
  • Fish liver oils (cod liver oil) are not the same as fish oil

Possible side effects

  • Fishy taste, bad breath, bad-smelling sweat, heartburn, nausea, diarrhoea and headache
  • Atrial fibrillation (irregular heartbeat)
  • Longer bleeding time; higher bleeding risk with prescription EPA ethyl ester
  • Raised liver blood tests (ALT) and, with EPA plus DHA prescription products, raised LDL cholesterol

Who should be careful

  • Pregnancy and breastfeeding
  • Children and teenagers
  • People with a fish or shellfish allergy
  • People with atrial fibrillation or other heart rhythm problems

Interactions listed

5 listed

  • Anticoagulants and anti-platelet drugs (for example warfarin-type blood thinners, aspirin-…
  • Statins (simvastatin, atorvastatin, rosuvastatin)
  • Warfarin (effect on INR blood-clotting tests)
  • Cod liver oil and other products with vitamin A or vitamin D

Read the full page →

Omega-3 oil

Algal (algae) oil

Algal oil is an oil from algae that supplies DHA, and in some products EPA, without using fish. In small trials it raised blood DHA about as well as salmon or fish oil. It lowered triglycerides but also raised LDL cholesterol, and…

What it is studied for

  • A fish-free source of DHA (and sometimes EPA)high
  • Raising DHA in the bloodmoderate
  • DHA status in vegetarians and vegansmoderate
  • Blood triglycerides and cholesterolmixed
  • Pregnancy and breastfeedinglow
  • Memory and thinking in older adults with mild memory declinelow
  • Children's reading and behaviourmixed

In short

Algal oil is a real fish-free source of DHA, and small trials show it raises blood DHA like fish oil does. Its effects on blood fats are mixed, and no trial shows it prevents heart disease. Evidence for pregnancy, memory and children is thin or comes from omega-3 in general.

Main safety points

  • No source answers whether people with fish or shellfish allergy can use it
  • It can raise LDL cholesterol
  • High amounts of EPA plus DHA were linked to more atrial fibrillation in people at high heart risk
  • Bleeding: no overall rise with omega-3, but high-dose purified EPA showed a modest one

Possible side effects

  • Unpleasant taste, bad breath, bad-smelling sweat, headache, heartburn, nausea, diarrhoea
  • Higher LDL cholesterol
  • Atrial fibrillation (irregular heartbeat)
  • Bleeding

Who should be careful

  • Fish or shellfish allergy
  • Pregnancy
  • Breastfeeding
  • Children and babies

Interactions listed

4 listed

  • Blood-thinning and antiplatelet medicines (such as warfarin, aspirin, clopidogrel)
  • Cholesterol-lowering medicines
  • Heart-rhythm medicines and existing heart-rhythm problems
  • Other omega-3 products (fish oil, krill oil, cod liver oil)

Read the full page →

Evidence labels (strong, good, mixed, limited, very limited, not enough, against) describe how strong the research is for each use, not how well something works for you. Different items are studied in different ways, so compare the strength of evidence as well as the topics.

Important: this is general educational information, not medical advice. Speak with a qualified healthcare provider before starting or changing a supplement, especially during pregnancy or if you take medicines. Our Medicine Interaction Checker can show known cautions with your medicines.