Skip to content
AlternativeMed

Compare Side by Side

Pick two or three supplements, herbs, teas or oils. You get an overview table, a goal-by-goal evidence chart, and the full details, all next to each other.

Comparing

Ashwagandha vs Rhodiola

Overview

AshwagandhaRhodiola
TypeAdaptogen
Adaptogens · Ayurvedic root herb
Adaptogen
Adaptogens · Arctic mountain root herb with low-certainty evidence
What it isAshwagandha is an evergreen shrub of the nightshade family. Its root, and sometimes its leaf, is taken as a powder, capsule or extract. It has been us…Rhodiola rosea is a hardy mountain plant in the stonecrop family. Its thick underground stem, usually called the root, is taken as an extract, capsule…
Best evidence Mixed results
for: Thyroid (a caution)
Mixed results
for: Mental fatigue and performance under pressure (students, physicians, c…
Uses studied12 listed
0 good · 9 limited · 3 very limited
22 listed
0 good · 8 limited · 14 very limited
Side effects listed1710
Who should be careful15 groups12 groups
Medicine interactions16 listed10 listed
PregnancyCaution or gap listedCaution or gap listed

Green outline = the better value in that row (stronger evidence, more well-supported uses, fewer side effects or interactions listed). A good score in one row does not make something the right choice for you.

Goal by goal

How strong the research is for each everyday goal. Empty means we have no study of it for that goal.

GoalAshwagandhaRhodiola
Focus & Memory Limited evidence
Memory, attention and executive function in healthy adu…
Mixed results
Mental fatigue and mental performance under pressure (s…
Blood Sugar Balance Mixed results
Body weight and body composition
–
Healthy Weight & Metabolism Mixed results
Body weight and body composition
–
Better Sleep Limited evidence
Sleep quality
Not enough evidence
Sleep and insomnia
Calm & Stress Limited evidence
Perceived stress
Limited evidence
Stress-related fatigue and burnout symptoms
Energy & Vitality Very limited
Fatigue and energy
Limited evidence
Stress-related fatigue and burnout symptoms
Joints & Mobility Limited evidence
Joint pain, knee osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthriti…
–
Healthy Aging Limited evidence
Quality of life and general well-being
–
Women's Wellness & Menopause Limited evidence
Testosterone in men
Not enough evidence
Menopause symptoms
Men's Vitality Limited evidence
Testosterone in men
Not enough evidence
Sexual function
Muscle & Performance Limited evidence
Muscle strength and size with resistance training
Limited evidence
Endurance and time to exhaustion
Inflammation Balance Limited evidence
Joint pain, knee osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthriti…
Very limited
Lung oxygenation and clot treatment in hospital
Mood Balance Very limited
Generalized anxiety disorder and OCD as add-on to stand…
Very limited
Mild to moderate depression
Immune Support Not enough evidence
COVID-19
Very limited
Lung oxygenation and clot treatment in hospital
Heart & Blood Pressure Very limited
Blood fats: triglycerides and cholesterol
Very limited
Heart conditions (angina and heart failure)
Healthy Skin & Hair Very limited
Skin and hair
–

Full details

Adaptogens · Ayurvedic root herb

Ashwagandha

Ashwagandha is an evergreen shrub of the nightshade family. Its root, and sometimes its leaf, is taken as a powder, capsule or extract. It has been used in Ayurveda for thousands of years, according to NIH and is now studied for s…

What it is studied for

  • Stresslow
  • Sleep qualitylow
  • Everyday anxietylow
  • Testosterone in menlow
  • Semen qualitylow
  • Muscle strengthlow
  • Menopause symptomslow

In short

Human trials are mostly small, short (4 to 12 weeks) and many used branded extracts. For stress and sleep most reviews rate the certainty of the evidence as low. Evidence for hormones, fitness and blood sugar is weaker or mixed. No long-term controlled trial exists.

Main safety points

  • Liver injury has been reported, and it can be serious
  • People with existing liver disease should not use it
  • Pregnancy and breastfeeding: avoid it
  • It can change thyroid hormone levels

Possible side effects

  • Drowsiness or sleepiness
  • Nausea
  • Stomach upset, diarrhea, loose stools, vomiting
  • Headache

Who should be careful

  • Pregnancy
  • Breastfeeding
  • Children
  • Older adults, especially those on several medicines

Interactions listed

16 listed

  • Thyroid hormone medicines (levothyroxine, liothyronine)
  • Benzodiazepines (for example diazepam, lorazepam, alprazolam) and sleeping pills
  • Barbiturates
  • Anti-seizure medicines (anticonvulsants)

Read the full page →

Adaptogens · Arctic mountain root herb with low-certainty evidence

Rhodiola

Rhodiola rosea is a hardy mountain plant in the stonecrop family. Its thick underground stem, usually called the root, is taken as an extract, capsule or tincture, mainly for stress and tiredness. Nothing about rhodiola is rated a…

What it is studied for

  • Stress-related fatigue and burnout symptomslow
  • Mental fatigue and performance under pressure (students, physicians, cadets)mixed
  • Attention, reaction time and memoryvery-low
  • Mild to moderate depressionvery-low
  • Generalised anxiety and everyday anxietyvery-low
  • Sleep and insomniainsufficient
  • Preventing altitude sicknessagainst

In short

Nothing about rhodiola is rated above low certainty. Stress and burnout: low (one small placebo-controlled trial and open-label trials). Mental fatigue: mixed. Depression, anxiety and thinking: very low. Altitude sickness prevention: the best evidence is against it. Physical performance: low, and two pooled analyses disagree. Safety data cover 12 weeks or less.

Main safety points

  • Short-term safety looks acceptable, but the safety record is thin
  • People with bipolar disorder, or who have had mania, should avoid it unless their psychiatrist agrees
  • If you take an antidepressant, talk to your prescriber first
  • Rhodiola modestly slowed one liver enzyme in people; this could matter for a few medicines

Possible side effects

  • Dizziness
  • Dry mouth, or too much saliva
  • Headache
  • Nausea, stomach pain, diarrhoea

Who should be careful

  • Allergy to rhodiola or past reaction to a product
  • Pregnancy
  • Breastfeeding
  • Children and teenagers under 18

Interactions listed

10 listed

  • Antidepressants that act on serotonin (SSRIs such as paroxetine, sertraline), and other se…
  • MAO-inhibitor antidepressants (such as phenelzine, tranylcypromine) and other MAO-blocking…
  • Medicines cleared by CYP2C9 with a narrow safe range (warfarin, phenytoin) and losartan
  • Medicines cleared by CYP3A4 or moved out of cells by P-glycoprotein

Read the full page →

Evidence labels (strong, good, mixed, limited, very limited, not enough, against) describe how strong the research is for each use, not how well something works for you. Different items are studied in different ways, so compare the strength of evidence as well as the topics.

Important: this is general educational information, not medical advice. Speak with a qualified healthcare provider before starting or changing a supplement, especially during pregnancy or if you take medicines. Our Medicine Interaction Checker can show known cautions with your medicines.